Astonishing Football 24 4+

Great game some minor improvements needed

I love the game there are just a few things in my opinion that would make it better. I think the fact that you only have your rookies on a 1 year deal (granted it’s zero dollars) it just makes it kinda hard. I think having them on a 3-4 year deal that is low contract and then having to pay them would be better.
Another thing is the team building. I could just be confused but I try to find a good balance between my strengths and the opposing teams weaknesses. But then I get game where I get blown out when I do that which shouldn’t make any sense.
Overall fun game just needs a few adjustments and it will be even better!

A rough approximation of football

The play selection is janky (and you can’t delete plays from your playbook or see any details about them other than their success rate), the game flow isn’t real (no halftime and kickoffs, punts kinda default start you at a certain distance even if the opposing team punted from midfield which should result in a longer field, not a shorter punt), the play selection and details information is obfuscated and contradictory (why do some passing plays have negative passing bonuses, why do defensive play descriptions not match the penalties they apply, why are medium and long passes used interchangeably, what is the yardage range and success rate of each play?), and the rosters kinda lock each game into starters playing 100% of snaps (which doesn’t let role players shine or really make much sense).

Feels like the game lacks a lot of polish (for one, adding custom image URLs don’t even get centered on the spot so logos are cut off and player headshots are off-center) but it also lacks the base level functionality of a game of football that actually makes sense.

Developer Response ,

Thanks for the feedback! I don't agree with everything you said, but it's still good to know. Take care!

Solid Game

The game overall is good has a great concept and works very well but the main problem that made me stop playing is that you only have 50 million salary cap so it makes it unrealistic and hard to make a good team and keep it good for more than like 2 or 3 seasons. I would also like for the rookies to have all four year contracts to start out with because in the game you have the rookies for like a season and then they leave because most of the time you spent your money on other players. Another problem I have with the game is that signing a free agent takes like 1/5 of your entire salary cap so your team can’t get better. The final problem I have with the game is that defense’s are way to bad like most players on defense are like a 55-70 making the games way to high scoring.

Overall a solid game to play for like 3 of 4 seasons until these problems start taking affect but overall a solid game.