Babysitting is an extreme sport in The Baby in Yellow, with supernatural troubles that make a wet diaper look like (ahem) child’s play. Get a taste of what awaits as we recount four of this horror game’s freakiest moments.

Barely a few minutes into your first night of babysitting, disaster strikes: The baby disappears from the changing table while your back is turned! Where’d he go? Does this have anything to do with his oddly glowing eyes?

The baby’s books are all fairly unsettling, but reading The Prince and the Sheep will rattle your already frayed nerves. As the narrator’s chilling voice utters each word, steel yourself for a freaky—and floating—outcome.

A secret passage, a maintenance room, and other cool discoveries await on the apartment building’s lower levels. Not quite as cool: a surprise encounter with a toothy ghoul! Better figure out how to escape, pronto.

By the game’s midpoint, the supernatural shenanigans have grown out of control. Dodging huge toy trains and building blocks while being pursued by a giant something (we won’t say what) gets pretty intense. And you’ve got to keep pace with the white rabbit that’s hopefully leading you to safety. Can you reach the exit?