Jersey Mike's 4+

The app is easy to use but if judging on effectiveness of getting the order correct I’m rating a 3 or 4. Main issues: why is spicey mustard not on the regular screen? You have to request as a customization. Therefore this got my order wrong recently because when I requested mustard I thought there was only one mustard and I happened to get to the restaurant while they were making it then psychologically it was an issue because I “knew” it was not the taste I was anticipating. Then there is the issue of Swiss versus provolone. Sorry, but provolone has very little flavor but for some reason Swiss is not listed as an option but it is an option in the store. This issue knocked down my rating today from 4 to 3 because I realize again I forgot to customize. NEXT, I want an option to not cut that sandwich in half - these are not finger sandwiches- they are designed to eat so half the ingredients don’t fall out the bottom. When you cut the sandwich in half you double the chance of the guts falling out. Next- I order to go... get a fountain soft drink- why is there no option to buy bottled drinks- I tried to grab one a while back but apparently those are charged differently. I’ve never seen anyone grab those. Why? Why aren’t they on the menu?

I’ve I’ve enjoyed jersey mikes for several years at many locations and it’s a good sub as long as they stick to the old ways and don’t cut corners for the sake of a few pennies. Sadly I’ve seen some skimping as of the past couple years. Unless that’s just the Inverness store. I’m quite excited to experience the newly opened store in Crystal River. I just made my first order and will pick up 10 minutes from this review. Will report back. I’ve enjoyed jersey mikes for several years at many locations and it’s a good sub as long as they stick to the old ways and don’t cut corners for the sake of a few pennies. Sadly I’ve seen some skimping as of the past couple years. Unless that’s just the Inverness store. I’m quite excited to experience the newly opened store in Crystal River. I just made my first order and will pick up 10 minutes from this review. Will report back. of you for making a great sub right on time for me to pick up on the drive home. I just enjoyed another club sub and I can’t decide whether I like the chicken kahuna better or not. Also thanks for the birthday points. Jay

We order from Jersey Mike’s quite often. One evening we used delivery as our method and we were given the wrong sandwiches by accident. Not only did they call us to tell us we got the wrong order before I could call them; they remade our order and gave us a free sub for next visit along with coupons for future visits. We were greatly impressed and have rarely experienced above average customer service in the food service industry. They made our night and owned the mistake. We recommend them over any other sandwich place in the area! We used to be frequent Blimpie buyers, but now we are thankful Jersey Mike’s is around, right in town and super delicious! Thanks Jersey Mike’s for making a quick sandwich that is tasty in Caldwell! They are super busy so I would recommend ordering via the online app and picking up in store. Another location by the D&B area in Caldwell off 20/26 would thrive like crazy as well. We have nothing over here!